Forget What You Think You Know About Nokia: It's a Buy
By: SumZero Staff | Published: September 06, 2012 | Read Comments (16)
Nokia: Focus on the margin of safety, not what you think you know.
Most people in North America (my main audience) have a mobile phone and at the very least a vague sense of what Apple is. Therefore most people have an opinion on the mobile phone market. You mention Nokia and they recoil in horror. This vague notion of what the company does and the associated behavioral tendencies have resulted in a truly outstanding investment opportunity.
By way of introduction, last year Nokia sold 417m handsets through over 850,000 distribution points (only 4m of those were in North America), they hold nearly 10,000 patents from which they earn €500m in recurring revenues each year, they own one of a few comprehensive local information and mapping databases globally upon which Microsoft are heavily reliant (and potentially Amazon), and they have a 50% stake in the world’s second largest provider of telecom equipment.
Most importantly, today Nokia is valued at between 120% and 77% of net cash plus patents depending on how you value those patents; you can forget the phones, the maps/data, and the networks business. Given that we know very little with certainty about the future the value on offer represents a very attractive margin for error.
It’s notoriously difficult to put a value on patents, some are essential, some are strategically important, and some are trivial. In 2011 Nokia effectively won its patent dispute with Apple which involved a “significant” lump sum payment for past infringement and “on-going” royalties, we have no details on what the numbers are but we do know that the overall annual royalty run rate for Nokia is touching €500m only three years after beginning to aggressively monetise their intellectual rights, this gives us a basis for determining their value.
If we assume €500m of royalty income per year for the average remaining life of the patents, tax this at the Finnish corporate tax rate of 26%, and discount the cash flows at Nokia’s WACC then the portfolio is worth €2.7bn. This is a very conservative scenario as it assumes no growth in royalty rates over the lifetime of the portfolio or strategic value but gives us the comfort of being based on cold hard cash flows.
If we add the net cash of €4.2bn to our first estimate of the patent portfolios worth of €2.7bn then the fundamental value of these two assets is €6.9bn, using instead the second estimate of patent worth we get a combined fundamental value of €10.7bn, the truth lies somewhere inbetween but they both compare favouribly to Nokia’s current market cap of €8.30bn. This alone makes Nokia an incredibly compelling investment prospect.
Nokia proved with their first Windows smartphone which was launched in only 10 months that they can still make good products (http://reviews.cnet.co.uk/mobile-phones/nokia-lumia-800-review-50005805/), and it has sold 7m units, nearly twice the number that the original iPhone sold at the same point in its lifecycle.
It's important to note that from a financial perspective that Nokia are far from turning the corner. This was evident in the most recent results where the operating margins in the combined devices and services business was negative 9% (there are inventory write-down and seasonal factors), but I believe that the building blocks are in place and the convergence of Windows 8 across platforms had the potential to drive significant success.
The success of Apples software/hardware integrated approach, Google’s acquisition of Motorola, Samsung’s intellectual property problems, and Microsoft’s choice of development path for the Surface tablet also suggest that Nokia could be an interesting strategic asset.
A vague notion of what the company does and the associated behavioral tendencies have resulted in a truly outstanding investment opportunity. There is compelling and definable value in the cash on hand and patents that Nokia hold which underpin the valuation today, and certainly a significant amount of less or undefinable value in the operating businesses.
Laura Mitchell September 17, 2012 edit |
A positive article about my former employer is nice to see. I am glad to know they are still considered a great investment opportunity. I will always bleed "Nokia blue."
Frank Ambrosio September 17, 2012 edit |
Isn't this what people were saying about Kodak a couple of years ago?
Robert Porter September 17, 2012 edit |
This company needs to show that it can make money. Cash flow has been shrinking as well.
September 17, 2012 edit |
The Microsoft Partnership should do wonders for Nokia but in 2-3 years.
Douglas Lukin September 17, 2012 edit |
No reference to cost structures, liabilities or if they have drawn on operating facilities in the past 3-5 years.
Pj Bartholomew September 18, 2012 edit |
Bjørn Alsterberg September 18, 2012 edit |
Skype + Nokia = Gold.
mayank tandon September 18, 2012 edit |
Nokia is certainly goona hit the market back thats for sure ,their new series is absolutely perfect.
johannes efstratiadis September 19, 2012 edit |
I bought 11.000 shares two weeks ago, Nokia will bounce back
alan davison September 19, 2012 edit |
Good start. This stock had an EV of zero at the bottom recently. That's something you rarely see. The mobile phone companies want a competitor to AAPL because they are sick of subsidizing the phones and Android has its problems. HTC today announced another MSFT phone. When Windows 8 arrives the networks will give them all a big push and not everyone can afford an iphone. If the new MSFT tablet works then MSFT will buy NOK to have veritcally integrated package. It's option money down here. I own plenty and I only buy value.
Jesse Tiwana September 21, 2012 edit |
It doesn't seem to be doing too well since this article was published. I'm heavily invested so hopefully it rises..
Marvin Gang September 21, 2012 edit |
In the last 3 months CVS shares have had a growth rate about double that of WAG. What is going to change to make the recommended pairs trade profitable?
Marvin Gang September 21, 2012 edit |
Sorry, previous post was attached to the wrong article.
gabriel petrean September 21, 2012 edit |
big risk...big return or...try
Brendan Fressola September 24, 2012 edit |
nok is severely undervalued and they know maps... they paid $8b (almost today's market cap) to acquire navteq almost exactly 5 years ago.... and Nokia Maps runs great.
peter schmid October 20, 2012 edit |
3.25$ as a 2-year target considering the amount of risk and volatility in stock - not sure about that one